Cumming
Peytons Pie Company - Gainesville

Peytons Pie Company - Gainesville

Eat Local in Gainesville

4.5 129 Google reviews$10–20

+1 678 943 29 00118 Main St SW Ste E, Gainesville, Georgia 30501

Peytons Pie Company - GainesvillePeytons Pie Company - Gainesville, photo 2Peytons Pie Company - Gainesville, photo 3Peytons Pie Company - Gainesville, photo 4

Where to find them

118 Main St SW Ste E, Gainesville, Georgia 30501

Free newsletter

More of Gainesville in your inbox

Local news, new businesses and what's on from Findit Lanier, once a week.

Get directionsOpen in Maps

About

A local, authentic pizzeria brought to you by Chef Nicholas St. Clair & his wife Alison St. Clair, of Top 100 Restaurant in America, Antebellum, in addition to Roland Stanley of Cork It in Gainesville. Peyton's Pie Company - named after his son, Peyton.

Amenities

Service options

  • Delivery
  • Onsite services
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Highlights

  • Fast service

Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

  • Alcohol
  • Beer
  • Comfort food
  • Quick bite

Dining options

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Counter service
  • Dessert

Hours

Friday
12 to 10 PM
Saturday
12 to 10 PM
Sunday
12 to 8 PM
Monday
12 to 9 PM
Tuesday
12 to 9 PM
Wednesday
12 to 9 PM
Thursday
12 to 9 PM

More Eat Local in Cumming

The Stag - Chophouse Restaurant
At The Stag Chophouse, situated in the heart of scenic Gainesville, Georgia, we take immense pride in offering an unforgettable dining experience that marries culinary excellence with the art of mixology. Alongside our mouthwatering selection of steaks, chops, and seafood, we boast an array of handcrafted, seasonal cocktails that will delight even the most discerning cocktail enthusiasts.
Chopblock Restaurant
A restaurant located at 110 Main St SW in Gainesville.
Sweet Magnolia's Cafe & Bakery Restaurant
Family owned café and bakery in the heart of downtown Gainesville! Homemade sides and goodies made daily!
TaqueriaTsunami Asian restaurant
Taqueria Tsunami offers a unique fusion experience, blending the vibrant flavors of Asia and Mexico. Located in Downtown Gainesville, Georgia, our innovative menu promises a variety of tastes with every meal with offerings of tacos, rice bowls, salads and quesadillas as well as margaritas and signature cocktails. Visit us and experience the unforgettable wave of flavor that is Taqueria Tsunami!
Cotto Modern Italian Italian restaurant
Cotto Modern Italian is a refined dining establishment featuring upscale Italian cuisine, located in the heart of downtown Gainesville. Prepare your palate for innovative flavor combinations, authentic pasta dishes, and wood-fired pizzas that are sure to tantalize any Italian food enthusiast. The full bar offers a variety of Italian inspired cocktails and a vast wine list featuring over 50 wines. Open for dinner throughout the week, the restaurant also serves a brunch menu on weekends beginning at noon every Saturday and Sunday. Reservations are suggested, but not required. Walk ins welcome. Cotto Modern Italian has been voted best Italian restaurant in Gainesville and Hall County, three years running in 2024, 2025, and 2026.
Collegiate Grill Hamburger restaurant
The Collegiate Grill, a beloved gem in Gainesville, Georgia, has been serving up delicious meals since 1947. This charming diner, with its retro '50s decor featuring black-and-white checkered floors and cozy red vinyl booths, offers a nostalgic dining experience. Famed for its mouthwatering American comfort food, the menu highlights include juicy burgers, hot dogs, and the popular double bacon cheeseburger. Each dish is made to order, ensuring freshness and flavor that keeps customers coming back. The casual, welcoming atmosphere makes it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With efficient service and a commitment to quality, The Collegiate Grill remains a must-visit spot for anyone craving classic Americana in Gainesville.
Atlas Pizza Pizza restaurant
Specialty pies, subs, wings, wraps & beer served in a no-frills cafe space with a pool table.
Avocados Restaurant American restaurant
Avocados offers freshly prepared, classic American eats, plus wine, local beer, and cocktails. Ample sidewalk seating offers prime people-watching, and inside the café is a warm and welcoming atmosphere.
Findit  Lanier

© 2026 Findit Lanier.


Findit Lanier covers the people, places, "things to do" and happenings that make Braselton, Buford, Cumming, Dawsonville, Hoschton, Suwanee, Sugar Hill , Lawrenceville and Gainesville, near Lake Lanier and parts of Hall, Forsyth Jackson, Barrow, Gwinnett, North Fulton and Hall counties in Georgia, that are worth paying attention to. Every issue gives readers a sharper sense of what is open, what is new, and what is worth their time in the community around them. Subscribe to stay connected to the Lake Lanier network that locals call home.

© 2026 Findit Lanier.